Ideologies: A Hindrance To Rationality?

ideology a hindrance to rationality

I was watching the press preview on Sky News last night as I often find myself doing and there were two journalists on the sofa having a right old barny over the benefits system (as is the current fashion for those involved in politics).

As each laid into the other’s remarks in scenes reminiscent of the playground, it got me thinking about how a person’s ideology can make him almost incapable of rational thought.

These two opposing journalists both seemed so sure that they were right and the other were wrong that they couldn’t see that there were merits in what both of them were saying.

As with many issues, climate change, and the actions required to prevent its most damaging effects, draw a lot of heated discussion but I’m certain that much of this is misguided by ideology in the same way.

I’m not saying that I am entirely impartial because clearly I am not; I believe climate change to be the biggest risk to our continued prosperity as a species and society. Last night, however, I may have had some sort of small lightbulb moment and it may just influence how I judge things in future.

I could very well ask myself: have I been too quick to write off fracking or waste incineration because of a lack of information? Did I perform thorough enough research when concluding that overpopulation isn’t the problem many make it out to be? Can the concept of natural capital really have a positive impact on the state of ecosystems that find themselves at risk?

The last of those questions is especially interesting because I dismissed natural capital after reading just a few short articles on the topic. I thought it was gut instinct that swayed me but it may well have been my own ideology. I definitely didn’t do enough research to allow me to draw a rational conclusion.

I’m going to have to give this some more thought but I’ll end by asking you – do you think you are driven by an ideology or are you able to keep an objective head on when making decisions?

Steve (156 Posts)

I am chief writer and editor on Green Steve. Blogging since 2011, I like to delve into a wide number of topics to help people reduce their carbon footprint. You should follow me on Twitter here. And add me to your Google+ circles here.

Hire Me - did you enjoy this post? Let me write thought provoking environmental and green living articles for your website or blog

Comments are closed.

Dealing With Recycling Apathy

I spend most of my working week in an office that I share with around 8 or 9 other people and despite having a green blogger in their midst, many seem fairly lax in their attitudes to recycling. We have on...
The Importance of Green Community Action Groups

If you read my last post about recycling apathy then you'll know that one of the things that I think holds individuals, communities and even countries back from genuine and massive action on climate change ...
The Curse Of “Stuff” And What You Can Do About It

So I have just completed the move into my new flat and despite a broken van wing mirror and heavy traffic it all went ok. The thing that shocked me during this move was just how much stuff I had which I nev...
Getting The Green Feel Good Factor

One of the most unexpected (and welcome) things I've experienced since I started this blog is the sense of accomplishment and the good feelings that come from my making this journey. Every time I make chang...
Compete with Caution: The Limits of Greening Behavior with Competitions

When an organisation decides to go green, the first question is the simplest: How do we do it? Often, one of the first answers to come to mind is to host a competition. In fact, do a web search for “going ...
Q&A With Ian Tennant From Greeniversity

So I recently spoke to Ian Tennant, who is the development co-ordinator for Greeniversity, a sustainable skills sharing scheme which is being rolled out across the country. I wanted to find out more about Gre...